• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Alampi & Associates

  • Welcome
  • About Jim
    • Speaking
    • Boards
    • CEO Peer Groups
  • Resources
    • Jim’s Minute Clinic
    • Alampi Leadership Assessment
    • Execution Library
    • Articles & Whitepapers
    • Software License Agreement
  • Clients
    • Clients Say…
  • Media
    • Video
    • Print
  • Store
  • Contact

October 16, 2017 By Alampi.com

Execution Challenge: When To Do More With Less

RIGHTSIZING IN A DOWNTURN

As companies face the stark realities of the current economic environment, many are having to consider the need to “rightsize” and the best reaction to this need. There are numerous potential solutions and each has pros and cons. The actions a company takes right now will become part of the company history; employees, ex-employees, suppliers and customers will remember how a company dealt with adversity. And the actions taken will clearly demonstrate whether the company stuck to its core values in tough times or abandoned them.

TAKE CARE OF YOUR “A’s” AND “B’s” IN A DOWNTURN

Every CEO faces alternatives regarding rightsizing his organization, and the typical options include:

  • Reduce staff, e.g. a 10% reduction
  • Reduce pay rates, e.g. a 10% reduction
  • Reduce hours, e.g. a 32 hour week

But the real question is not what to do, but how to do it. Do we take action across the board, i.e. all departments and levels? Or are we selective? If we cut heads, what happens to the remaining employees’ workloads? What tasks or functions can we stop doing?

The typical thinking is that to be fair, everyone and all departments should share equally in the pain. The problem with that thinking is that if we have differentiated our employees per Bradford Smart’s business classic, “Topgrading”, we know we have “A” player stars and “C” players who cannot be successful in their current jobs. What message do we send our stars if we lump them in with everyone else? And what will happen when times improve and “A” players remember how they were treated? “A” players can always find new positions, and with their exodus comes the potential challenge of trying to lead a company with an over-heavy concentration of “C” players.

Classic management of human resources has often theorized that, “everyone is in this together and we want to be fair.” There are leaders who truly believe that differentiating among people (topgrading) is unfair, but read Chapter 3 of Jack Welch’s latest book “Winning” for one of the best articulations of why it is not only fair but critical in organizations.

There is a contemporary stream of thought that makes a strong case for unequal pay and perks, based on sustained, demonstrated performance as companies rightsize. All positions in a company do not have equal importance to achieving the mission, and all people do not perform at the same level. The idea that our best people should suffer the same pain as our poorest performers may seem fair, but it is illogical in terms of the people who are most important to achieving results. As Richard W. Beatty, who teaches human resources management at Rutgers University observes, “Look, there are an awful lot of long-term employees who are poor performers who have locked-in high salaries through cost-of-living increases.”

As companies develop plans for reacting to the current economy, individual employee performance and topgrading become critical decision points for how to apply actions in the right way. Actions taken now must not only consider the realities of today, but also preserve the company core, ready for profitable growth coming out of this economic downturn.

Some good reading includes:

Making the Case for Unequal Pay and Perks, Michele Conlin in BusinessWeek, March 12, 2009

A New Game Plan for C Players (HBR OnPoint Enhanced Edition)

“A Players” or “A Positions”? The Strategic Logic of Workforce Management

 

Filed Under: Execution Challenge

Primary Sidebar

When Hindsight Can Be as Good as Gold

 Imagine starting your business over with all the knowledge you have gained since those early, trepidation-filled days of … [Read More...] about When Hindsight Can Be as Good as Gold…

Our Clients Say...

At Sanimax we operate in a segment of the Agriculture industry that is down to earth and practical. A lot of what we do is instinctual and historically… Read More...
We used Jim Alampi for several years to facilitate our annual and quarterly strategic planning meetings. In a short time using The Execution Maximizer… Read More...
Jim has been a real pleasure to work with both personally and professionally for the past 5 years.
He helped us develop an execution rhythm and muscle…
Read More...
Having just taken over as CEO, it was extremely important to get this first planning session right. Jim’s rare combination of street smarts and practical… Read More...
Jim has a proven formula for integrating the framework of The Execution Roadmap with guided strategic sessions that challenge the thinking of our executive… Read More...
Since starting our strategic planning process under your guidance I have seen a renewed passion and commitment to results in my team. I especially value… Read More...
Great job Jim. This was our third strategic planning meeting with you and again I was impressed by how much you understand our company — both strengths… Read More...
We are a 105 year old company and never have established core values, a mission statement or defined our purpose. Jim Alampi’s The Execution Roadmap made… Read More...
Jim has been an important part of regular strategic planning and the goal setting process at R. L. Polk & Co. He has provided us with structure, challenge… Read More...
Jim Alampi has worked with our Corporate and divisions operations teams for about two years. We found him particularly adept in helping us deal with complex… Read More...
Jim provides extraordinary value by bringing new ideas and perspectives to the strategic planning process. He is phenomenal at gaining alignment, identifying… Read More...

Great To Excellent

BRAND NEW BOOK! From the award-winning business leadership speaker Jim Alampi, ACCELERATING STRATEGIC EXECUTION presents a unique system to identify, … More... about Store

From The Library

Execution Challenge: Invest or Let Go?

Leaders know that their #1 competitive advantage is their … Read More... about Execution Challenge: Invest or Let Go?

Execution Challenge: When To Do More With Less

RIGHTSIZING IN A DOWNTURN As companies face the stark … Read More... about Execution Challenge: When To Do More With Less

Execution Challenge: Dealing With Bad News First

One of the key differences between good and great companies … Read More... about Execution Challenge: Dealing With Bad News First

FollowOnTwitter

Subscribe

Jim regularly shares insights from his decades of experience fine tuning the strategies of business leaders and their teams. Subscribe and get these informative and helpful "coffee cup" briefs that will help put your day into a new perspective!
  • Welcome
  • About Jim
  • Resources
  • Clients
  • Media
  • Store
  • Contact

Copyright © 2023 Alampi & Associates · Website By The Unicom Group · Log in